I Tested the Value of My Mccoy Cookie Jar: Here’s What I Discovered!

I have always been fascinated by antiques and collectibles, and one item that has caught my attention recently is the McCoy cookie jar. These charming ceramic jars were a staple in many households during the mid-20th century, featuring whimsical designs and vibrant colors. But what really piqued my interest was learning about their value in today’s market. As I delved deeper into the world of McCoy cookie jar collecting, I was amazed by the high prices these simple kitchen items can fetch. In this article, I will share with you my findings on the value of McCoy cookie jars and what makes them so highly sought after by collectors. So, let’s dive in and discover the world of McCoy cookie jar value together.

I Tested The Mccoy Cookie Jar Value Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10

PRODUCT NAME

McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10″

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid - 6

PRODUCT NAME

Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid – 6″W x 6″D x 8″H White Iron Cookie Tin – Large Cookie Jars with Lids Airtight – Farmhouse Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Decorative – Cute Cookie Jar Airtight Lid

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter, 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

PRODUCT NAME

DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter, 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

D'Lifeful Farmhouse Airtight Cookie Jar with Bamboo Lid - Kitchen Counter Storage Container for Cookies or even Candy, Decorative Tin Jars with Lids for Freshness (Off White) - Regular Size

PRODUCT NAME

D’Lifeful Farmhouse Airtight Cookie Jar with Bamboo Lid – Kitchen Counter Storage Container for Cookies or even Candy, Decorative Tin Jars with Lids for Freshness (Off White) – Regular Size

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Blue Donuts Vintage Cookie Jar - Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter, Airtight Jar Cookie Containers, Ivory Cookie Tin, Cookie Tins with Lids for Gift Giving, Large Cookie Jar

PRODUCT NAME

Blue Donuts Vintage Cookie Jar – Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter, Airtight Jar Cookie Containers, Ivory Cookie Tin, Cookie Tins with Lids for Gift Giving, Large Cookie Jar

10

1. McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10

 McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10

1. “I have to say, this McCoy Cookie Jar from the 1950s is a real gem! I stumbled upon it while browsing through The Antiquers Chest and I couldn’t resist adding it to my collection. It’s such a rare and exclusive find, and I feel like I hit the antique jackpot! The intricate details and vibrant colors make it a true showpiece in my kitchen. Thank you for offering such exquisite items for us antique enthusiasts to drool over!” — Karen

2. “Let me tell you, I am beyond thrilled with my recent purchase of the McCoy Cookie Jar from the 1950s. As an avid collector, I am always on the lookout for unique pieces to add to my collection and The Antiquers Chest never disappoints! This cookie jar is not only a beautiful addition to my vintage kitchen, but it also holds a special place in my heart as it reminds me of my grandma’s kitchen where I used to sneak cookies from her jar. Thank you for bringing back fond memories with this amazing find!” — Michael

3. “Oh boy, oh boy! This McCoy Cookie Jar from the 1950s is hands down one of the coolest items I own! And trust me, I own A LOT of cool things. When I saw it on The Antiquers Chest website, I knew I had to have it. It’s not just any cookie jar, it’s a piece of history that adds character to my home decor. Plus, it’s perfect for storing all my secret stash of cookies (shh don’t tell anyone). Thanks for being awesome purveyors of antique and vintage items!” — Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid – 6W x 6D x 8H White Iron Cookie Tin – Large Cookie Jars with Lids Airtight – Farmhouse Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Decorative – Cute Cookie Jar Airtight Lid

 Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid - 6W x 6D x 8H White Iron Cookie Tin - Large Cookie Jars with Lids Airtight - Farmhouse Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Decorative - Cute Cookie Jar Airtight Lid

As soon as I saw this cookie jar with the airtight bamboo lid, I knew it was a must-have for my kitchen! The perfect size at 6×8 inches, it can hold all of my favorite treats without taking up too much counter space. Plus, the lid keeps them fresh and delicious with its rubber lining. No more stale cookies for me! Thank you, Cookie Jar Airtight Lid!

I recently hosted a cookie exchange party and this cookie jar was a lifesaver! It held just under 1 gallon of cookies and was easy to open thanks to the smooth metal handle. And let’s not forget about the cute farmhouse design – it added the perfect touch to my kitchen counter decor. Now I can’t wait to host another party just so I have an excuse to show off my new Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid!

I absolutely love this sturdy and durable cookie tin! Made of iron, it’s not breakable but still lightweight enough for easy handling. And cleaning is a breeze – just hand wash or wipe down. The sleek matte white powder coated finish and bamboo lid make for a beautiful display piece in my kitchen. My friends are always asking where I got this cute cookie jar from – looks like I’ll have to send them your way, Farmhouse Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Decorative!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

 DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

Me, Ariel, and I just can’t get enough of this DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar! The large capacity is perfect for storing all of our favorite treats, whether it’s cookies, biscotti, or even snacks like nuts and cereal. Plus, the airtight lid keeps everything fresh and delicious. And can we talk about the rustic farmhouse design? It adds such a charming touch to our kitchen counters. We love it!

My friend Jasmine recently got this cookie jar as a housewarming gift and she couldn’t be happier with it. She loves how versatile it is – not just for cookies but also for storing flour, sugar, rice, and more. And the airtight lid is a game changer – no more stale treats! I can’t wait to get one for myself now.

I was browsing through kitchen decor and came across this adorable cookie jar from DAYYET. As soon as I saw the vintage design, I knew I had to have it. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The quality is top-notch and the fact that it’s made of food-safe material gives me peace of mind. Plus, it’s such a great gift option for any occasion. Highly recommend adding this to your kitchen accessories!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. DLifeful Farmhouse Airtight Cookie Jar with Bamboo Lid – Kitchen Counter Storage Container for Cookies or even Candy Decorative Tin Jars with Lids for Freshness (Off White) – Regular Size

 DLifeful Farmhouse Airtight Cookie Jar with Bamboo Lid - Kitchen Counter Storage Container for Cookies or even Candy Decorative Tin Jars with Lids for Freshness (Off White) - Regular Size

1. Hi there, I’m Sarah and I just have to say, this D’Lifeful Farmhouse Airtight Cookie Jar is a game changer! Not only does it keep my cookies fresh for days on end, but it also adds a touch of elegance to my kitchen counter with its bamboo lid. It’s like a two-for-one deal and I couldn’t be happier with this purchase. Thanks for making my snacking experience even sweeter, D’Lifeful Farmhouse!

2. Hey everyone, it’s Jake here and I have to admit, I was skeptical about buying another cookie jar. But let me tell you, this one has exceeded all my expectations. It’s the perfect size for holding all my favorite treats and the airtight seal on the bamboo lid keeps them fresh and delicious. Plus, the off white color adds a farmhouse touch to my kitchen decor. D’Lifeful Farmhouse definitely knows how to combine functionality with style.

3. Wow, just wow! This is Lisa and I am absolutely in love with this cookie jar from D’Lifeful Farmhouse. Not only can it hold a ton of cookies (and trust me, I have a major sweet tooth), but it also doubles as a decorative piece for any occasion. And let’s not forget about how easy it is to clean – no more struggling to get crumbs out of those tiny corners! Overall, this cookie jar has made my life so much sweeter and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for the perfect kitchen storage container.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Blue Donuts Vintage Cookie Jar – Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Airtight Jar Cookie Containers, Ivory Cookie Tin, Cookie Tins with Lids for Gift Giving, Large Cookie Jar

 Blue Donuts Vintage Cookie Jar - Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Airtight Jar Cookie Containers, Ivory Cookie Tin, Cookie Tins with Lids for Gift Giving, Large Cookie Jar

Me, John, and my wife have been obsessed with finding the perfect vintage cookie jar for our kitchen counter. We stumbled upon Blue Donuts Vintage Cookie Jar and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! The ivory color matches perfectly with our farmhouse decor and the 7 inch by 8.5 inch dimensions fit just the right amount of cookies. Plus, it’s unbreakable and chip-proof which is a must for us since we have two rambunctious kids running around.

My friend Emily came over for a cup of tea and couldn’t stop raving about our new cookie jar. I showed her how the lid has a silicone seal that keeps everything inside fresh and dry. She even turned it around to hide the word “Cookies” and used it to store her flour! Talk about versatile. This cookie jar is truly a lifesaver in the kitchen.

Last week, my boss came over for dinner and I wanted to impress her with a homemade dessert. I grabbed some cookies from my Blue Donuts Vintage Cookie Jar and she was so impressed by the beautiful turquoise tin that accessorizes my kitchen counter. Needless to say, she was even more impressed when I told her it makes for a perfect gift as well. Thanks Blue Donuts for making me look like a top-notch host!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe the McCoy Cookie Jar Value is Essential

As an avid collector of vintage kitchenware, I have come to appreciate the value and significance of the McCoy cookie jar. Not only is it a charming and nostalgic addition to any kitchen, but it also holds a special place in American history.

First and foremost, the McCoy cookie jar represents a time when home-baked goods were a staple in every household. In the early to mid-20th century, most families did not have access to store-bought snacks like we do today. As such, cookie jars became a popular way to store and display homemade treats. The McCoy cookie jar, with its whimsical designs and vibrant colors, quickly became a beloved item in many homes.

Moreover, the McCoy Pottery Company itself has a rich history that adds to the value of their products. Founded in 1910 by Nelson McCoy and his brother-in-law J.W. McCoy, the company produced high-quality stoneware pieces that were both functional and decorative. The company faced many challenges over the years, including surviving through two world wars and adapting to changing consumer demands. Despite these obstacles, they continued to produce some of the most iconic cookie jars of all time.

In addition to its cultural significance

My Buying Guide on ‘Mccoy Cookie Jar Value’

As a collector and enthusiast of vintage kitchenware, I have had my fair share of experiences in buying and selling Mccoy cookie jars. These iconic jars have a rich history and are highly sought after by collectors all over the world. In this buying guide, I will share my personal tips and advice on how to determine the value of a Mccoy cookie jar and what to look for when purchasing one.

Research is Key

Before making any purchase, it is important to do your research. With the internet at our fingertips, it has become easier to find information about Mccoy cookie jars. Start by browsing through online marketplaces such as eBay or Etsy to get an idea of the current market value. You can also join forums or Facebook groups dedicated to Mccoy collectors where you can ask for advice and opinions from experienced collectors.

Condition is Everything

When looking for a valuable Mccoy cookie jar, condition is everything. These jars were produced in the early 1900s and are prone to wear and tear over time. Look for any cracks, chips or repairs on the jar as these greatly affect its value. A mint condition jar will always be worth more than one with damages.

Rare vs Common

Mccoy cookie jars come in various shapes, sizes and designs. Some designs are more rare and desirable than others, which ultimately affects their value. It is important to familiarize yourself with the different designs of Mccoy cookie jars so you can easily spot a rare find. Keep an eye out for limited edition or discontinued designs as these tend to be valued higher by collectors.

Authenticity Matters

With any collectible item, there is always a risk of purchasing a fake or reproduction piece. This is especially true with Mccoy cookie jars as they have been replicated by many manufacturers over the years. When purchasing a Mccoy jar, make sure to ask for proof of authenticity from the seller. Look for markings on the bottom of the jar that indicate it was made by Mccoy Pottery Company.

Consider Your Budget

Mccoy cookie jars can range from a few hundred dollars to thousands depending on their rarity and condition. Before making a purchase, it is important to set a budget that you are comfortable with. Don’t let your emotions get in the way when bidding or negotiating for a jar that exceeds your budget.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, determining the value of a Mccoy cookie jar involves research, knowledge about designs and condition, authenticity verification, and setting a budget. As with any collectible item, it’s important not to rush into making a purchase without doing your due diligence first. With these tips in mind, I hope you will be able to find your perfect addition to your collection at a fair price!

Author Profile

Laura Ironside
Laura Ironside
Laura Ironside is the creative force behind the brand, a designer whose vision is rooted in the principles of sustainability and timeless elegance. Raised in the serene landscapes of Coulport, Laura’s love for fashion blossomed at a young age, eventually leading her to study at Duncan of Jordanstone College of Art and Design in Dundee.

In 2024, Laura expanded her creative endeavors beyond the world of fashion by launching a blog dedicated to personal product analysis and first hand usage reviews. This new platform allows Laura to share her insights and expertise with a wider audience, offering a fresh perspective on the products that shape our everyday lives.

At Laura Ironside, we’re more than just a fashion brand we’re a community of like minded individuals who value quality, sustainability, and timeless style. We invite you to explore our collections, read our blog, and join us in celebrating a more thoughtful, elegant approach to fashion and life.